Showing posts with label Common Core. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Common Core. Show all posts

Common Core Workshop Resources - Day 2

Hope you are finding the resources I've been posting from the Oklahoma Geometry and Algebra Project to be useful/inspiring/helpful.  If you missed the notes from Day 1, click here.  Here's my notes from Day The Second:

Advice: "If it's not about the students, just say NO!"

The most valuable classroom time is the very beginning and very end of class.  Sadly, these are also the most wasted times.

Recommendation: Use Exit Tickets to maximize end of class.  And, use Tickets In The Door to maximize the beginning of class.

Tickets in the door were a new concept to me.  Here's how they work: give students a short assignment that they must have the next day to enter your classroom.  Students who have not completed the assignment cannot enter your classroom until it is completed.

You can use a tool like Remind101 (now just named Remind) to remind students of their upcoming ticket in the door.

"You have to be at least a little bit uncomfortable to be learning!"  

Sine Solution


After a quick review of the unit circle, we got out our graphing calculators to work through another activity from the Balanced Assessment in Mathematics Project.

Sine Solution

The file for this activity and an answer key can be downloaded here.  I'll be teaching trig for the first time this next school year, and I'm excited to use this activity in that class!  I'm sure my students will be shocked to realize that the answers to 1-3 are all the same!  Should lead to a great conversation about why...

Formulas and Function Notation


The next activity we worked through was an example of how we could take something we were already doing in our classroom and raise the rigor of the activity.  For example, we expect our Algebra 1 students to be able to rearrange literal equations to solve for any variable.  A typical problem would read: "Solve the formula C = 2*pi*r for r."  Not exactly exciting.

To step these problems up a notch, we were asked to write the equation for the area of a circle as a function of its circumference.  Or, write the equation for the area of a circle as a function of its diameter.  Another: write an equation for the volume of a cube as a function of its surface area.

As we sat and worked through these problems, we really had to think.  Were these super hard questions?  No.  But, as teachers, we can get so used to always approaching something a certain way that it can take a minute to reorient yourself when a question is asked differently.  We weren't just going through the motions and solving for a single variable.  Instead, we had to look at both equations, see what they had in common, determine which equation to solve for that common variable, then plug the result into the other equation.

Paragraph Function


There are tons of ideas out there on the Internet for data collection activities for linear, quadratic, and exponential functions.  But what about rational functions?  Those are rare!

This activity comes from a collection of data collection activities for an introductory physics class.  You can download the file here. The same publishing company that made this file available for free has some other files online that may be of interest.

Paragraph Functions Activity

The activity begins by giving students this page of paragraphs to measure.  Ask students: what is constant on this page?  What is changing from paragraph to paragraph?

Measure the width (x) and length (y) of each paragraph.  Record your data in a table and create a scatter plot.  Predict the mathematical model that would best represent this data.  Find a regression equation that models this situation.  Why is this appropriate?

To be honest, my unit on rational functions has always been BORING.  I'm hoping that my students will be able to see why this must be modeled by a rational function.  After all, would it ever be possible to have a width of zero?  Can't wait to try this out with my students!  (Plus, it also fits in some much needed measurement practice.  My students are the WORST at reading rulers.)

I Really Gotta Go!  


After working through some basic constructions, we moved on to an activity called I Really Gotta Go!

We received a paper that had three points, labeled A-C, and these instructions: There are 3 playground areas in the park indicated by A, B, and C.  The recreation department wants to place restroom facilities so the will be an equal distance from each playground.  Show where the restroom facilities will be located.

I had trouble with this activity.  I bisected each side of the triangle, but I wasn't sure what to do afterwards.  One of my tablemates was able to show me what to do next.  Geometry really is one of my weak areas.  I haven't really needed to do geometry since I took the class in the 9th grade!

Too Hot to Handle


The last activity of the day was from NCTM Illuminations.  It's called Too Hot To Handle.

Too Hot To Handle

You can download all the resources for this activity here.  Because we were running out of time, we had to slightly modify our data collection.  We put the thermometer in the water, removed the thermometer, and recorded the temperature every 10 seconds.  The actual activity calls for you to leave the thermometer in the water and record the temperature every 3 minutes.

It was suggested that you could have your students research several of the questions from the worksheet packet before doing the project.  They could even be a ticket in the door!  For example, have students research "What temperature is considered scalding? or "At what temperature is it safe to take the first sip of coffee?"

Gligs and Crocs


One of our homework problems was a task called Gligs and Crocs from the Balanced Assessment in Mathematics Project.

Gligs and Crocs

You can download the file for this activity as well as an answer key from the Balanced Assessment website.  This problem was a fun little challenge.  My first attempt at working out this problem did not go well.  But, I regrouped, tried a different approach, and succeeded.  This is one of those problems that doesn't have a pretty answer.  But, I should give my students more problems with messy answers.  They shouldn't immediately think that they got something wrong just because they got a fraction/decimal.  

Other Random Notes


Website Recommendation: Inside Mathematics

Ask Students: "What's your takeaway for the day?"

If you're using technology to replace student thinking, that's inappropriate!

If using technology encourages student thinking, that's appropriate!

Technology doesn't have to plug in or have a battery.    

Common Core Workshop Resources - Day 1

Here is the first of five posts wrapping up what I learned during the second and final year of the Oklahoma Geometry and Algebra Project (OGAP).  

First off, I want to thank the people who made this amazing experience possible.  The workshop was coordinated by Dr. Jennifer Bryan from Oklahoma Christian University and Dr. Martha Parrott from Northeastern State University - Broken Arrow.  The workshop was facilitated by Linda Hall and Martha Wissler.  Linda and Martha are both retired math teachers from Edmond Public Schools, and they are phenomenal!  I have learned SO much from them.     


The first activity we were given was to sort 12 statements.  We weren't given any more guidance than that.  Each group was given the same 12 statements.  Here's how my group sorted them:


Statements about what teachers should do in the classroom.  Strategies that were at a lower-level on Bloom's Taxonomy were placed below strategies that were at a higher-level.


Statements about what teachers should be doing in the classroom.  Same ordering of thinking skills.


And, statements about what math instruction in general should be like with the same structuring as above.


I sadly didn't take a picture of the other groups' groupings, but they were vastly different from ours.  It was interesting to see how differently the same set of statements could be grouped.

It turns out that these statements were taken from Principles to Actions, a recent publication of NCTM.  In Principles to Actions, these statements were sorted into two columns with the headers "Productive Beliefs" and "Unproductive Beliefs."  As part of the workshop, we received a copy of Principles to Actions: Ensuring Mathematical Success for All.  As one of our homework assignments, we had to read several sections of it.  I've really enjoyed what I've read so far, and I'm looking forward to delving into it further.  I may never get my Summer Reading List done now since I keep adding new books to read!     

Principles to Actions

One of the reasons I'm looking forward to reading it is that the chair of the writing team was Steve Leinwand, the author of Accessible Mathematics: Ten Instructional Shifts That Raise Student Achievement which I read and LOVED last month!  You can see my review of that book here.

This wasn't the only resource we received.  Going to one of these workshops is kinda like Christmas!  We each picked a subject to specialize in this year.  Last year, I chose Algebra 1.  This year, I decided to switch my focus to Algebra 2.  Basically, we have to collect data from one of our classes.  We give that class a pre-test and post-test as well as having them make concept maps at the beginning and end of the school year.  The class we focus on is the class we will collect our data from.

We received a new textbook from Big Ideas Math for the subject we chose to specialize in.  I haven't had a ton of time to peruse the text yet, but the first thing I noticed was how much thinner the textbook was from a normal textbook.  This line of books was written specifically for Common Core.  I'm hoping I will be able to pull out some great problems to use with my students from this text!  

Big Ideas Math - Algebra 2 Textbook

Probably the best resource we got during the week was a 3-inch binder packed with activities!

OGAP Binder

Several of the activities we did during the week were from The Charles A. Dana Center.  Last year, we received a cd of Algebra Formative Assessments Through The Common Core.  This year, we received Geometry Formative Assessments Through The Common Core.  Each cd has pdfs of 3-4 different books on it!    

Formative Assessment Resources from The Dana Center

We joked that the next book we received would be considered contraband in our schools now.  Even though Oklahoma has pulled out of Common Core, I still found my reading in The Common Core Mathematics Standards: Transforming Practice Through Team Leadership to be relevant to my teaching practice.  Whether we are teaching CCSS or not, shifts are happening.  And, this book talks about what needs to happen to make these shifts possible.

The Common Core Mathematics Standards

One resource we didn't use a lot of this week was our copy of the Common Core State Standards for Mathematics.  Actually, I used it three times during the week.  But, all three of those times involved me turning to the reference sheet to look up a formula!  Next year, I am definitely going to make a reference sheet for my students to keep in their interactive notebooks!

CCSS Standards

Now that you're jealous over all the awesome goodies I got, I'm going to share the resources we were given on Day 1.  Enjoy!

The Camel Problem


The first problem we worked on in our groups was the camel crossing the desert problem.  I had just seen this problem the previous week in the copy of Discovering Advanced Algebra that I ordered off of Amazon.  I remember reading the problem and thinking it sounded interesting, but I hadn't spent any time trying to solve it.

Clipart from ClipArt ETC - one of the best sources for free clipart for the classroom! 


The version we attempted reads as follows:

A camel is sitting by a stack of 3000 bananas at the edge of a 1000 mile-wide desert.  He is going to travel across the desert, carrying as many bananas as he can to the other side.  He can carry up to 1000 bananas at any given time, but he heats one banana at every mile.  What is the maximum number of bananas the camel can transport across the desert?  how does he do it?  Be prepared to present your solution to the class.  (Hint: the camel doesn't have to go all the way across the desert in one trip.)  

My group got right to work and figured out a way to transport 500 bananas across the desert on our first try.  Linda looked at our solution and told us that we could do better than that.  We tried, but ever subsequent strategy ended up transporting less than 500 bananas!  One group was able to arrive at the solution during the 45 or so minutes we were given to work on the problem.  The rest of us had to take the problem home for homework.  At home, I tried to solve the problem by employing simpler cases.  But, I never did make the breakthrough I needed.

The next day, they provided us the solution.  I kinda wish I had left the room during the explanation so I could have figured it out for myself.  Oh well...  There are plenty of other math problems out there for me to solve!

Fawn Nguyen gives her students a version of this problem that involves transporting 45 watermelons across a 15 kilometer desert.  I think this problem would be much more approachable for my students.  Plus, you can easily represent 45 watermelons with manipulatives.  I wouldn't want to try to represent 3000 bananas!  I definitely want to work this problem into my curriculum next year!

Linear and Exponential Model Scavenger Hunt


Next, we moved to an around the room scavenger hunt style activity from Howard County Public Schools.  If you're still in a Common Core inclined state, the alignment is F.LE.A.1.  10 graphs were hung around the classroom.

Picture of Graphs for Scavenger Hunt Activity

As you can tell, some of the graphs are linear, and some are exponential.  We were given pages with 10 equations, lettered A-J, 10 tables, lettered A-J, and 10 verbal models, lettered A-J.  The facilitator assigned each group the letter of the graph they would start on.

Now, I've done scavenger hunt style activities in my classroom, but I've never done one quite like this before.  A timer was set for 2 minutes, and we had to stay at the graph we had been assigned for those 2 minutes.  On our answer sheet, we had to record the letter of the table, equation, and verbal model that matched up with the graph we were standing in front of.  When the timer went off, we had to move as a group whether we were ready or not.  As we became more accustomed to the activity, the time we were given at each station was decreased to 1 minute.

Some of the groups HATED that everything we were matching was labeled with the same sets of letters.  So often, someone in my group would say something like, "This has to match H!"  Another person would look at them like they were crazy.  "It can't be H!"  It would then turn out that one person was talking about the table and the other was talking about the equation!  We had to attend to precision with our speaking during this activity.  Since I have such a small classroom, the student groups would be very close together if I was doing this activity with them.  By reusing the same letters, students can't just listen to the group ahead of them and record their answers.  "Okay guys.  Our next answer is going to be B."  Was it B on the equations, tables, or verbal models???

I've never timed my groups before during this type of activity, but I think I'm going to try that this year.  In the past, I've let groups move at their own pace, and that means some groups whiz through the activity and other groups do nothing all hour.  Hopefully this will help both of those problems!

You can download the files for this scavenger hunt activity here.  You will need to scroll down to where it says "HCPSS UDL Lesson: Comparing Linear and Exponential Functions."

Strategies To Reach Out To Struggling Students


* Build relationships with students so there is trust!

* Focus on the 3 R's
        - Relationships
        - Rigor
        - Relevance

* Get the math out of the textbook, and put it into the lives of students!

* Turn mistakes into learning opportunities.

* Use individual white boards to increase students' willingness to attempt a problem.  I've found that my students are more willing to try a problem if they can easily erase it if they mess up.

* Say to students: "Explain to me how you got here."

* Go back to see what your students are actually struggling with.  If they are having trouble simplifying radicals, go back to multiplication.  Can they fill out a multiplication chart?  Start here.

* Color code the steps of your math problem.  Allows students to ask safe questions.  "How did you get the blue part?"  A student who struggles with math vocabulary would be more willing to ask this question as opposed to trying to ask a question using vocab he doesn't know and sound foolish.
* Class time needs to consist of comparing and discussing MULTIPLE solution methods.

* Ask / Expect students to EYB - Explain Your Brain.

Contrasting Cases

The next activity we worked through was a rotating station activity.  There were three stations set up around the room.  At each station, we were presented with two different ways of working a problem.  And, we were asked specific questions about the different solution methods.

You can ask students three different types of questions through an activity like this:

 - Which is better?
 - Why does it work?
 - How do they differ?

The problems we looked at involved a conversation of sorts between Alex and Morgan.  Here's an example:

Contrasting Cases Example
This was an example of asking the question "Which is better?"

Is anyone else excited about this?  You're going to be especially excited when I tell you that there is an entire Algebra 1 curriculum of these that you can download for FREE!

These are from a project entitled Using Contrasting Examples to Support Procedural Flexibility and Conceptual Understanding in Mathematics by researchers from Harvard, Vanderbilt, and Temple University.

Here's a direct link to where you can download these curriculum materials as PDFs.  But, I'd suggest taking a look around the rest of their site, too!  This study showed that student achievement improved when students were routinely presented with multiple ways to solve a problem.  As teachers, we can have a tendency to show our lowest students only a single way of doing a problem for fear that we will overwhelm them with multiple methods.  But, our students need to realize that there are many different and correct ways to solve a problem.  If we're not showing them this, we're cheating them!

I'm excited to look through their curriculum more closely and see what I can use this year!  If you find any awesome resources, send them my way!

As one of our facilitators said, "When students are analyzing, they are thinking!"

Another quote I jotted down in my notebook: "Make students into thinkers - not a location for dumping information."

Chemistry Dilemma


Ahhh!  The dreaded mixture problem!  Bonnie and Carmen are lab partners.  They need a certain mixture of X% acid and Y% water.  But, they only have access to a mixture of A% acid / B% water and C% Acid / D% Water.  Whatever can they do?

The specific problem we worked is under copyright by the Dana Center, so I can't post it here.  But, I can tell you about how we approached this problem during the workshop.

We were given a blank chart with the following columns

Amount of Mixture A
Amount of Mixture B
Amount of Acid in New Mixture
Amount of Water in New Mixture
% of New Mixture is Acid
% of New Mixture is Water
Acid/Water Correct Mixture?

Since we needed 5 ounces in our example problem, we first tried out 1 ounce of Mixture A and 1 ounce of Mixture B.  We used percents and multiplication to find the new amount of acid and water.  Then, we divided by the total number of ounces to calculate the percentages of acid and water in the new mixture.  In the last column, we had to decide if we had too much acid or too much water and adjust accordingly.

In our example, we ended up with too much water, so we tried a different break-up of the 5 required ounces.  We repeated and repeated and repeated the process.  Eventually, we discovered that 4 ounces of Mixture A gave us too much water in our final mixture.  5 ounces of Mixture A gave us too much acid in our final mixture.  Therefore, we needed somewhere between 4 and 5 ounces of Mixture A, and we went from there.

It was a ton of work to work the problem out this way, but I think it would really help students to see how the process works.  I've never actually done mixture problems with my students before.  They're not tested, so I've always conveniently skipped over them.  The presenter said that she used to teach her students how to set up the system of equations, but they never really understood where the numbers in the equations were coming from.

You definitely wouldn't work every mixture problem out this way.  That would be insane!  But, doing the process once should help students visualize the process and better understand why a system of equations can be used.

I can also see myself using this as a quick review of percents/proportions/decimals/etc.  Then, revisit the problem when you get to systems.

Casey's Quesadillas


The last problem of Day 1 was Casey's Quesadillas from The Dana Center's series of Geometry Formative Assessments.  Casey has a map of downtown.  He draws a circle on the map of where he would like to advertise his food truck.  Rewrite the equation of his circle in vertex form.  Decide where Casey should place his quesadilla cart.  It then proceeds to review the meaning of radius and the distance formula.

I can see myself using this activity in Algebra 2 during our unit on conic sections.  It reminds me of Dan Meyer's Taco Cart.

Homework


Our homework assignment included completing a series of Short Tasks from MARS (Page 2 of this pdf.) This was easy and straight forward.  Then, we were to complete a task from the Balanced Assessment in Mathematics Project called Three Circles.


This one took a bit of thinking!  At first, I was sure that they hadn't given us enough information.  But, I was soon able to set up a system of equations and solve for the radii.  Great problem!

You can download this task from the Balanced Assessment Program here.

Overwhelmed yet?  This is just Day 1 of an AMAZING workshop!

Disclosure: This post contains Amazon Affiliate links.  

Common Core - Come and Gone: My Experiences as a Classroom Teacher

I spent all last week at a Common Core workshop for teaching Algebra 1, Algebra 2, and Geometry.  If you're not from Oklahoma or you don't keep up with education news, you might not realize the irony of the previous statement.  At the beginning of this month, Governor Fallin signed HB 3399 which repealed Common Core in the state of Oklahoma.  Instead, we are going to revert to our old standards for two years while we write out own new set of standards which will be more rigorous than Common Core.  I'm scared to even think about what those will look like.  

When I entered the teaching profession, I knew next to nothing about Common Core.  My professors in college told us that it was on the horizon, but they did nothing to prepare us for the upcoming change.  They assured us that our school districts would have a transition plan and provide training.  Ha.  Ha.  Ha.

I ended up accepting a position working in a school district whose Common Core transition plan involved hanging posters of the standards on the walls and saying we had transitioned.  Meanwhile, I had coworkers who had never even heard of Common Core.  When you mention Common Core to a math teacher and get a blank stare in return, that's not a good sign.  The English teachers in my district assured the administration that there was no difference between Common Core and what they were already teaching.  I was regularly told that no action or changes on my part were required.  After all, Common Core wouldn't be around for long.  We didn't really need to worry.  I guess they were right in this case...  But, won't they just say the same thing about the next set of standards?  Will my district ever embrace change?    

Meanwhile, I am looking at the CCSS Math Standards, and I am overwhelmed.  The topics I am teaching my Algebra 1 students will soon be 7th and 8th grade standards.  The topics I am teaching my Algebra 2 students will soon be Algebra 1 standards.  Some of the standards ask my students to prove things that I don't even know how to prove off the top of my head.

With no support from my district, I sought out my own Common Core training.  I listened to webinars.  I read blog post after blog post.  And, when I heard about a week-long training program through the Oklahoma Geometry and Algebra Project, I jumped at the chance to attend.

Since I teach in a low-performing district, I knew that the transition was going to be rough.  Our high school offers no math remediation classes.  So, I have to fit that remediation in during the school year or my students won't have access to it.  This slows me down and means that I can't cover as much curriculum as I would like.  If a student is struggling in Algebra 1, there is no other place for him or her to go.  There is no Algebra Concepts class or extra support class.  It's a sink-or-swim environment.  I will openly admit that I teach to the test.  If a topic isn't tested, there's a 95% chance that I don't teach it.  I just don't have enough time.  If I had a room full of students on Day 1 who could add, subtract, multiply, and divide positive and negative numbers, I would be in heaven.  There is no Pre-Algebra class to send them back to to learn this.  If my students can't work with integers, it's my job to teach them that.  So, yeah, my Algebra 1 students are the students that Geometry teachers complain about because they enter their classroom having never used the distance formula or the quadratic formula.  Sorry, but it's not on my test.  And, if you are going to tell me that my students can't graduate without passing the Algebra 1 EOI, I'm going to do my best to make them pass the test.  I owe that to my students.  

When I talk to teachers in larger, more urban districts I get jealous.  If a student isn't successful during the first semester of Algebra 1, they are pulled out and placed in a support class for the rest of the year.  This student is then not required to take the end-of-instruction exam, and the school's report card will not be affected.  Teaching in a small district, we do not have this luxury.  I see technology and resources that they are able to provide their students that we just can't afford.  I teach in the type of district that has been re-buying the same textbooks since 2004 so they don't have to throw away the old copies.  If you looked at my school's report card you would see a C-.  As someone who has made a grand total of 1 B in her life, a C- is hard to stomach.  Average the three schools in my district together, and the state of Oklahoma deems us a D district.  

(To be fully honest, there are perks to working in a small district.  But, that's another post for another day.)

As hard as I knew it was going to be, I was ready and up for the challenge for teaching Common Core.  I was ready to raise my expectations and push my students to their limits.  After working for the past two years to prepare to transition to Common Core, I feel like I've been slapped in the face by the state legislature.  With one bill, they've thrown out countless hours of hard work by teachers.  And, that doesn't even begin to mention the amount of money the state spent on the transition.

In a way, I was dreading this week of Common Core Training.  I thought it would be 5 days of complaining about the repeal.  But, our facilitators reminded us that good mathematics teaching is good teaching whether we call it Common Core or not.  Since the workshop was grant-funded, the workshop had to continue to focus on Common Core since that was what the grant stipulated.  Common Core was helping to move me away from teaching the way I was taught.  Just because our standards are going backwards, it doesn't mean that the way I teach has to.  I can (and should!) still provide my students with questions and problems that promote higher-level thinking and perseverance.  We can still attend to precision and choose appropriate tools to solve problems.  Higher expectations don't have to die with the repeal of Common Core.

It was amazing to get together with other teachers and look towards the future.  The overall attitude of the conference was upbeat and positive - something I definitely needed!

This week, I hope to get my notes from each day typed up.  It's a way for me to reflect on what I learned.  It's a way for me to share resources with others who are looking to improve their teaching of math.  And, it's a way for me to be able to search back through my notes - something I can't do if they're stuck in a notebook or binder.      

In the meantime, if you're hungry for resources, feel free to look through the resources I posted from last year's week-long workshop.

Starting to Dig Geometry?

I set down today to write a post about an awesome geometry activity I got to experience last week at a workshop.  However, I'm afraid you're going to have to read about my unfortunate experience with a mouse in my house first.  

It's a rainy Monday.  After living out of a suitcase for 22 of the past 28 days, I'm enjoying this day at home with only one thing on my agenda: Friends of the Library Board Meeting.  How I spend the rest of the day is entirely up to me!  So far, I've spent my morning doing endless loads of laundry, rearranging my bookshelves, reading a bit here and there, and working on deep-cleaning my house, one room at a time.  Other people spring clean.  Not me.  Let's be honest; teachers don't have time for spring cleaning.  I spend my spring stressing over standardized test prep and the million and one activities that are going on at school.

So, what's the occasion for my cleaning?  It's called "Oh my goodness.  A mouse has been in my house cleaning."  In six years of living on my own, I've never had to deal with a mouse before.  Let's just say I'm not handling it all that well.  You might even go as far as to say that I'm over-reacting.  What exactly is the proper first step to take up discovering a mouse has taken up residence in your house?  I'm going to bet it's not the text I sent my mom or the phone call I made to my sister.  To my mom: "I think it's time for me to move and find a new place to live.  I just saw a mouse in my house!"  I mean, either way, somebody has to leave.  It's either the mouse or me.  Though moving is on my top ten worst things in the world list, it may or may not have just moved down a spot.

Of course, my mom was full of sympathy.  She responded, "It could be worse.  You could have a bear in your house."  Thanks, Mom.  That's really helpful.  I guess I do have to give her credit for buying me one of those mouse traps that doesn't require you to touch the mouse when you dispose of him.  It's currently setting in the floor of my bedroom.  I'm starting to think that my little mouse friend isn't attracted to the all-natural, preservative-free peanut butter I keep in my fridge.

When I called my sister to tell her about my unfortunate run-in with the mouse, I started the conversation, "I need to get married.  ASAP!"  Why?  "So my husband will have to deal with the mouse, and I won't have to."  She told me that she was sure I would get right on that.  Since I don't sense any imminent proposals, I'm trying to act like the grown-up that my birth certificate says I am.  The mouse is currently still winning, but not for long!  I will prevail.  And, my house is looking better by the minute!  Silver linings...

Enough about the mouse.  Let's talk about archaeology.  I spent 5 glorious days last week at NSU-BA as part of the Oklahoma Geometry and Algebra Project (OGAP).  So much fun!  So much learning!

On the first day of the workshop, I walked in the room, and my eyes were immediately drawn to the table along the wall that held the supplies we would be using for the week.  There were thermometers, bags of play sand, work gloves, protractors, compasses, rulers, and SO MUCH CANDY.  I was incredibly curious about how play sand was going to find its way into a math lesson.

Monday passed, and the play sand remained on the table.  Tuesday came and went without any activities involving sand.  Surely we would get to play with the sand on Wednesday!  Nope.  Finally, on Thursday, we entered the classroom to see that a metal bucket had been filled with the sand.

I doubt you know this (unless of course you're my sister - Hi sis!), but I've always thought it would be so much fun to be an archaeologist.  I was that kid who used to wish for a metal detector.  Okay, I still wish I owned a metal detector.  My parents never did give into that request.  I'm pretty sure my mom didn't want the yard full of holes.  I just think it would be so exhilarating to unearth ancient artifacts!  But, I would not make a good archaeologist.  I'd probably get fired for complaining too much.  You see, I don't handle dirt well.  I don't like getting dirty.  So, having a job that involves digging in the dirt probably wouldn't be the best fit.  Plus, I hate, hate, hate hot weather.  Oklahoma summers can be awful, and the air conditioner is my best friend.  

Since I doubt I'll ever get a chance to pursue archaeology, I was excited to get to try my hand at an archaeology dig during the workshop.  The workshop facilitators urged us to use caution in this activity to avoid injury.  One person per pair was instructed to come to the bucket, don a pair of work gloves, and use the Mickey Mouse/Cars trowels to unearth an ancient artifact to carry back to their desk and trace.  I actually let my partner do the digging so I could document the process with my camera.  After digging in the sand, my partner unearthed a shard of pottery.  It looked like it was once part of a plate.

Our Archaeological Dig Site 
Our task was to calculate how big the original plate was that our shard belonged to.  Then, we were to compare the measurement we found to the other groups in the hope that some of our shards might fit together to form a more complete artifact.

Our first step was to trace our artifact on plain copy paper.  This was a little tricky.  And sandy.  

Tracing of Our Artifact

I didn't actually remember to take a picture of our artifact.  But, here's the artifact of the other group sitting at our table.

Another Group's Artifact

Once we had our artifact traced, we had to decide on a strategy.  How could we figure out how large the original plate was?  Our first instinct was to measure the arc length.  That wasn't much help.  We had been assured that the plates were not broken in the center.  So, how could we find the actual center?

This wasn't the first time I had had this dilemma.  On Monday, we had to take a pre-test.  I usually do quite well on these types of things, but this test had several problems that stumped me.  On the test, there was a drawing of a piece of the top of a broken glass coffee table.  Given this piece of the broken table, instruct your friend what size of circular glass table top he needs to purchase.  After measuring the two sides and finding them to be different lengths, I was stumped.

Here I was again.  Same problem.  Different context.  Still stumped.

I guess my table looked lost/confused/dazed because one of the facilitators came over to give us a little shove in the right direction.  She told us that we needed to draw two chords.

My geometry is a bit rusty, but I can still draw chords.  Now what?  Thankfully one of the others at my table had taught geometry recently and remembered that the perpendicular bisector of a chord always goes through the center of the circle.  Once we found the perpendicular bisector of each chord, all we had to do was find where the bisectors intersected.  Then, it was just a matter of measuring the radius!    

And, yes, I did label my paper "Artifact A."  I'm cool like that.


Constructing the Center of Our Plate

How fun is this activity?!?  It kinda even makes me want to teach geometry.  This was, by far, one of my favorite activities from the 5-day workshop.  I've always thought constructions were kinda cool, but I've never seen them as useful before this activity.    

Here's our reconstructed artifact: 

Putting the Pieces Together

After completing the project, we had a discussion on how to adapt this for our own classroom.  We decided that maybe using an actual broken plate wasn't the best idea.  A kid could easily get hurt.  One teacher suggested cutting up Chinet plates for the activity.  Another said that you could break the plate and just hand out the tracings.  Keep the artifact in a ziplock bag so the kids could see it but not touch it.

Here are the instructions we were given in our binder:

Materials
* Large, flat, plastic pan for the digging site
* Ceramic plates of varying diameters - broken into 4 pieces with at least 3-4 inches of outside rim and not ending at the center
* Play sand
* Compass
* Protractor
* Pencil
* Plain Paper

Student Instructions
* Each pair of students should dig for a piece of the artifact.
* Trace the shape of the artifact on paper.
* Using any manipulatives or tools in the classroom, find the radius of your object.
* Find the other groups that have the same measurement and fit the pieces together to form the original artifact as best as you can.

Have you ever done anything like this in your classroom?  Can you see yourself using this activity?  Please share!  

I'll also accept your commiserations regarding my new (and hopefully very temporary) house guest.

Common Core Resources from OGAP Training - Summer 2013

Summertime means sleeping in (sometimes), attending workshops and conferences galore, my church's annual turtle race to celebrate the end of VBS, and mowing the lawn.  It also means looking through ideas to implement during the next school year.  I love leaving a workshop or conference with a binder full of great ideas.  But, when in need of inspiration, I usually turn to the Internet for help - not my shelf of giant binders.  This summer, one of my goals is to get organized.  And, one way I can do that is to type up my conference notes.  Then, I can use my blog's lovely search feature when I'm looking for something!  Smart, right?  Plus, these resources might also inspire one of my readers.  Double win!

As I prepare to attend my second summer of the Oklahoma Geometry and Algebra Project (OGAP), I'm revisiting my notes from last summer's conference.  Enjoy!

BOOK RECOMMENDATIONS DURING WORKSHOP
NCSM Great Tasks (6-12)
Strength in Numbers: Collaborative Learning in Secondary Mathematics (Just Finished. SO GOOD!)
MPJ's Ultimate Math Lessons
A Visual Approach to Functions


We should strive to have students build, model, and reflect instead of memorize and regurgitate.

Have students construct their own parabolas.  (Blogged about this one here - Wax Paper Parabolas)

Article Recommendation: Faster Isn't Smarter: Messages About Math, Teaching, and Learning in the 21st Century by Cathy L. Seeley

Partner Problems - identical to Kate's Row Game
Slope Example (Page 4-5 of PDF)

G.C.A.2 Tangent Lines Application from HCPSS

Insects In The Water Quadratic Functions Activity from Dana Center

How Do They Fit? Tarsia Activities (Square Puzzles) from Public Schools of North Carolina

Play Graphing Scattergories 

Demonstrate Composition of Function using Peanut M&M's - Can't find exact link for this.  Here's an example where Peanut M&M's are used to explain the Chain Rule in Calculus

True Colors Personality Test - Blogged About Here and Here

Collaborative Learning Tips:
* Make sure everybody in the group has a specific job.
* Focus on 1 Problem
* Don't expect every group to finish
* Give each group only one copy of the question - encourages cooperative work!

Paper Cup Review Strategy
* Gather 10ish review problems you would like your students to complete.
* Place each review problem in a paper/plastic cup.
* Around Easter time, you could place each problem in an easter egg!
* Assign each person in the group a job.
 - Traveler - Selects problems and directs consensus
 - Reader - Makes sure the group understands the question
 - Recorder - Makes sure that each person is recording all problem solutions
 - Question Seeker - Leads dialogue by asking, "Does this make sense?" or "How do we know" or "Why?"
* Give each student a recording sheet.  (Empty square for each review problem.)
* Traveler goes to front of room and selects a cup.
* Group works together to solve that problem.  All students must agree on answer.  All students must show work on their own recording sheet.
* Can change group roles halfway through the activity.
* Ideal to have most groups finish 7-8 problems.
* Perfect semester test or standardized test review.
* Give every student a full copy of every question and every answer at completion of activity.
* When grading: Engagement > # of Problems Solved

Introduce function notation through a family tree example.  Taken from 1987 issue of Mathematics Teacher.  Online PDF of activity  (I tried this activity with my Algebra 2 students.  They were not at all familiar with the structure of a family tree.  Very confusing for them!)  Aligns with F-IF.1 and F-IF.2

Illustrative Tasks: A Sum of Functions (F-BF.A.1)

Bouncing Tennis Balls Task from NCTM Illuminations (S-ID.6 and S-ID.7)
Blogged about this activity here.

Use Move the Monster Activity to Introduce Transformations
Blogged about this activity here.

If your students are struggling with solving equations, introduce them to the do/undo method.  This method is especially great for solving literal equations.  Aligns to A-REI.3 and A-REI.1.  Tie in with wrapping a present analogy.  Actually wrap a present in front of the class.  See a foldable I made for this method here.

Find the Weights Problem from Problems With A Point
Great Introduction to A.REI.11 and N-Q.2
Introduction to Systems of Equations
Emphasizes Perseverance and Repeated Reasoning

Algeo Problem from Problems With A Point
With 8th Grade Common Core Geometry, this may be an Algebra 1 level problem.
Give students a page with 26 boxes to show work in.
My tablemates had a blast with this problem during the conference!

All Tied Up In Knots Lab for Solving Systems of Equations
Link to Instructions
Aligns to A.REI.6 and S-ID.6 and S-ID.7
(Note: Make the fatter rope the longest!)

Slide and Divide Factoring Strategy when a>1
(I taught this method this year, but I am not in love with it.  Next year, I will only be teaching factoring by grouping!)
Aligns to A-REI.4

Common Core requires Algebra 1 students to be very comfortable with finding/interpreting the discriminant!

Fun Factoring Practice
Page 20 of this PDF File

Fruit Loop Catapult - Can't find link to activity.  Sorry!

Our kids need to stop thinking like the book has taught them to think.  #1 should not be the easiest.  #25 should not be the hardest.

A Trip To The Lake
A-REI.11
A-REI.7
A-REI.10
F-BF.4.A
F-IF.4
F-BF.1.A
Give each group a large piece of graph paper!
First page is appropriate for Algebra 1
Entire activity is appropriate for Algebra 2
Don't put origin at bottom of graph.
Link to file

MARS Sorting Functions Activity
F-BF.1.A
F-IF.7
F-IF.9

The Constant Chair - Can't find activity online.  Sorry!

Exponential Growth and Decay with Skittles

Dice - NO FIVES Activity
Give each group 50 dice.  Students roll dice.  Remove all 5s.  Record remaining number of dice.  Roll dice again.  Remove all 5s.  Record.  Roll, Remove, Record.  Continue until you run out of dice.  have students identify the domain and range of their data.  Sketch a scatterplot.  Determine what type of regression would be appropriate.  Find the regression equation.  What does the y-intercept of this equation mean in the context of the problem?

The Case of the Cooling Corpse
F-BF.1.B
F-LE.1
F-LE.5
I really wanted to do this activity this year with my Algebra 2 students, but we ran out of time!

Illustrative Tasks Lake Algae
F-BF.1

PISA Released Items - Great source of Common Core style questions!
M159 Speed of a Racing Car would make a great bellwork problem!
PDF File (Page 29)
F-IF.4

Community Center Problem
PDF Page 15
F-IF.4, F-IF.5, F-IF.6
We added several other questions to this activity.
I did this problem with my Algebra 2 students this year, and they struggled with it majorly!  I gave it as a homework assignment that most did not turn in.  The students who came to me for one-on-one help were able to grasp the activity, but few came to me for help.

How Tall is Harold?
PDF Page 14
From CPM
Algebra 2 - Systems of Equations (Quadratics)

Interesting Shadow Problem (Similarity)
PDF File #5
Not the answer you would expect!  If I taught geometry, I'd definitely use this problem!

Four Cars Activity From Dana Center
Link to PDF
Refer to "Rate of Change" not "Slope"
Extension - graph everybody in your group's car.


Full Disclosure: This post contains Amazon Affiliate Links

Oil and Natural Gas Production Profit Lesson

The first lesson I implemented from the OERB Core Energy Mathematics Workshop I attended was on Oil and Natural Gas Production Profit.  I did this lesson with my Algebra 1 students as a review of writing equations based on a real-life situation and as an introduction to solving systems of equations.

I modified the worksheets we were given at the workshop to create two foldable booklets that could be glued in our interactive notebooks.  I was hoping to get through both booklets in one 50-minute class period, but that was super optimistic.  In reality, it took 1.5 class periods to complete these problems.

Oil and Natural Gas Production Profit Booklet Foldables

Before jumping into the lesson, we had a group/class discussion.  What do you know about the oil and natural gas industry?  I had students discuss their own personal knowledge in groups.  Then, each group shared with the class.  I really need to work on my discussion leading skills because the discussion was not as fruitful and productive as I would have liked.  My students think they can get away with having their own conversations while other groups are presenting.  And, I end up yelling a lot.  But, it never seems to do any good.  I think it's because I've never taken the time to teach them the procedures of a class discussion.  I need procedures.  I need consequences.  And, I need to be consistent about them from Day One.  I just ordered a book on orchestrating productive mathematics discussions, so I'm hoping to learn from that this summer.

Some students offered insights into the oil and natural gas industry that were way over my head.  They were throwing around jargon that meant nothing to me.  These were the students who have actually spent time on rigs and worked out in the field alongside family members.  Other students offered insights such as "Oil smells funny."  or "You put gas in your car."

The Essential Question for this lesson was "How do oil and natural gas producers determine if wells are feasible to drill?"  Students were to come back and answer this question AFTER completing the lesson.


We also needed to review some important vocabulary before beginning to work with numbers and equations.


As we worked through each of the questions together as a class, we would continually refer back to this vocabulary box.  If a question mentioned profit, we would review the definition of profit before even attempting an answer to the question.  These terms were new to almost all of my students.  They had a really hard time differentiating between operating costs, profit, and revenue.

Day One focused on answering questions related to this data:


This could be updated to reflect the actual current selling price of a barrel of oil, but I just used the data that was provided at the workshop.  Oil prices tend to fluctuate a lot.

Here's the first batch of questions we explored together:


After reviewing the vocabulary, students were able to complete this section with relatively few problems.  The function notation proved tricky for several of my lower level students.  Many students would just wait until someone in the class provided the answer.  I hate this, but I'm not sure what to do about it.  I guess  I could give everybody in the class a different set of data to work with, but that would probably drive me INSANE!

Having written functions for revenue and operating costs, students could now tackle the topic of profit.


This is where we ended Day One.

Day Two.  Your company is now ready to drill a well!


Now, we've moved from discussing one wellsite to comparing two wellsites.

Again, we're practicing function notation.  This time, students are told what to name their functions.


Now comes the fun part.  Graph the two functions.  Figure out where they cross.

This was really hard for me to do, but I did it anyway.  I didn't tell my students how to number their axes.  I let each class pick.  I was risking that some classes might not find a graphical solution.  Why do this?  Well, this is math.  This is real-life.  In real-life, every decision has consequences.  My students need to learn this.  They need to learn that math isn't always pretty.  It can be messy.  Sometimes you have to try multiple approaches to something before you find the way that works.

Handing my kids a graph with the axes already marked cheats them and me out of a learning experience.  My kids need to see the consequences to their decisions.  If I choose for them, I'm cheating them out of an opportunity to think critically.  To be an effective teacher, I need to know what my students are thinking.  I need to know how well they can think critically.  If I choose for them, I'm cheating myself out of learning more about where my students are.  The more I know about where my students are, the more I can help them get to where they need to be.

In this class period, students decided to let each line on the y-axis represent $1,000.  And, each line on the x-axis represented 5 days.  We started to graph A(x), the cost of drilling wellsite A for x days.  My students quickly identified the y-intercept of the equation, and we marked that on our graphs.  The slope was a little trickier.  How in the world do you graph a slope of 200?  First, I asked my students to rewrite 200 as a fraction.  200 was soon expressed as 200/1.  The numerator of our slope represents the change in y of our function.  What is the change in y of our y-axis?  The distance between each line on our y-axis represents $1,000.  The denominator of our slope represents the change in x of our function.  What is the change in x on our x-axis?  The distance between each line on our x-axis represents 5 days.  Now, how can we "unreduce" our slope so that the numerator is a multiple of $1,000 and the denominator is a multiple of 5?  Students soon realized that 200/1 is equivalent to 1000/5.  Instead of spending a ton of time trying to estimate how to go up 200 dollars and over 1 day on the graph, we were able to quickly and efficiently move up 1000 dollars and over 5 days.  

This is a strategy I learned at the OERB workshop.  This was a completely new strategy to me, and I kinda sorta fell in love with it.  We're always asking our students to reduce the slope.  But, I don't think I've ever asked students to "unreduce" their slope before this lesson.


I let the students take more charge on graphing B(x).  Again, we had to "unreduce" our slope of 250/1.  This class ended up multiplying the numerator and denominator by 10.  Going up 2500 dollars and over 10 days was a little trickier since every other dot was not on the intersection of two grid lines.  In retrospect, we could have corrected this by multiplying the numerator and denominator by 20.    

We found the point of intersection of the two graphs and wrote this solution to the system as an ordered pair.

Next, I asked students to algebraically determine the solution.  Since we were only beginning our study of systems of equations, I had to basically set up this problem for my students.  Once I set up the equation, they were able to easily manipulate the variables to solve for x.  Finding the corresponding cost by substituting the found value of x into one of the cost functions did not occur to them.


Next, students were required to write exactly what this found ordered pair meant.  My students struggled with the writing which is proof that I need to require a lot more writing in my classroom.  With Common Core, my students need to get used to justifying their answers.  Even more, they need to get used to writing in complete sentences.  Always using units.  Showing their work.  We've got a lot of work to do!  


This is the first extended application problem that I have worked through with my students.  I enjoyed the process, and I learned a lot.  I hope my students learned a lot, too.

Their answers to the essential question were disappointing.  But, I think that's mostly my fault for just expecting them to write when I haven't required that of them for the entire year.  My students will rise toward my expectations.  But, first I must set expectations.  This is one of the major things I am working on for this summer.  Procedures and expectations.  Clearly spelled out.  Practiced Daily.

I have uploaded the files for this activity below.  Credit for the lesson goes to the OERB.  I have slightly modified some of the wording and structure to make it work for my students.

If you have trouble accessing these embedded files, send me an e-mail at mathequalslove (at) gmail (dot) com, and I'll happily attach the files and send them to you!




Disclosure: This post contains Amazon Affiliate Links.  

Drawing Pictures: Reflections on Problem Solving

The more I teach, the more I learn.  Eventually, I'm going to become pretty great at this job.

The summer before my first year of teaching, I made a set of problem solving strategy posters to hang on the wall.  My first year of teaching, these posters had an entire bulletin board dedicated to them.  I would occasionally reference them in class, but I didn't really do anything substantial with them.  

Problem Solving Strategies Bulletin Board
This summer, I redecorated and rearranged my classroom.  In order to make room for a Star Student bulletin board, I moved the problem solving strategies to a new home underneath my SMART Board.

New Home for Problem Solving Strategy Posters
I don't even think most of my students ever even noticed that they were there.  Again, I did nothing more than post them on the wall.

If I really and truly want my students to develop their problem solving skills, I have to do more than just post the strategies.  I have to make them do the strategies.  I have to make them practice the strategies.  I have to remind them of the strategies.  But, it's more than that.  I have to give them challenging problems that will force them to utilize the strategies.  If I'm not challenging them, if I'm not holding to them to a high standard, then it's pointless to even post the strategies.

This year, I opted to skip the unit on ratios and proportions in Algebra 1.  Under Common Core, ratios and proportions will be a middle school unit.  And, I knew that my students had seen these types of problems in middle school.  Since this is the last year of testing our old standards in Oklahoma, students were asked several problems involving ratios, proportions, and percents on their end-of-instruction exam.  During our few weeks of EOI test review, I threw these ratio/proportion problems up on the board to see how my students would handle them.

Here's one of the problems I chose from questions released by the Oklahoma Department of Education:

At a candle store, the ratio of green candles to red candles is 2 to 5.  The store has 4,900 candles.  How many candles are red?

This is a tricky question.  When students see that 2 and 5, their gut instinct is to make a ratio out of them and then form a proportion.  4,900 isn't the number of green or red candles, though.  It's the total number of candles.  So, we need a ratio that deals with the total number of candles.  We must represent the ratio of red candles to total candles as 5/(2+5).

Knowing that students were likely to be tripped up by this problem, I urged them to draw a picture before performing any calculations.  It was a simple request.  It was a request that I should make more often.

Draw me a picture.

A.K.A. Use a problem solving strategy!

And, don't just use it.  Use it, and then show the class how you used it.

Oh, you used a strategy but ended up doing something incorrectly?  Awesome!  You just provided me with insight to your thought process, and it's an excellent learning experience for the class.

I didn't realize just how powerful that question would be until students started holding up their dry erase boards with their pictures.

Let's just say that the way I approached this problem and the way many of my students approached this problem was differently.  When I asked for a picture, I had a certain picture already drawn in my mind.  So, when students started holding up pictures that were unlike what I expected, it was an awesome experience.  I had to grab my camera and document this experience!

I wasn't expecting a circle graph.  But, it works!  And, I almost wish I had thought of drawing my picture like this.

Circle Graph

Another student thought in terms of writing the ratio using a colon.  Many students in the class could relate to this.  Again, it wasn't what I was going for.  But, that doesn't make it a viable picture.

Ratio

This student also used the colon format to write their ratios.  She has made the common error that I predicted upon picking out this problem.

Ratios

Of course, some students drew pictures that were creative but not exactly mathematical.

I present to you: Sherrie's Candle Store

Picture of Candle Store

When I drew my picture on the board, I drew two green candles and five red candles inside a lovely store.  (You can tell me just how awesome of an artist I am in the comments!)  Realizing that red and green candles were the color of Christmas candles, I changed the name of my store to the "Christmas Candle Store."

Next, I drew the sideways squiggly bracket, and I asked students how many candles were represented by the picture I drew.  4900 candles.  How many candles did I draw?  7 candles.  So, how many actual candles must each drawn candle represent?  700 candles!  Once this discovery was made, my students were quick to point out that the correct answer was (d) 3,500 red candles.  Why?  After a satisfactory answer was given, I drew the circle graph that one of my students had drawn on their board on the SMART Board.

What if your picture looked like this?  What would you do next?  We walked through the same solution process using a different picture.

Illustrating the Question

Why have I never done this before?  I draw pictures on the board all the time.  But, I don't have my students do the same.  I've been cheating them out of a learning experience by drawing the picture for them.  I've been cheating myself out of a learning experience by not letting them draw their own pictures.  I guess I've always been afraid that their pictures would be wrong.  I've been afraid that they would make mistakes.

This stops now.  Will they make mistakes?  Certainly.  Mistakes are how we learn.  I've always thought that, but my actions haven't been reflecting that in my classroom.

I'm currently reading a book on how to organize my house/life by setting up daily/weekly/monthly routines.  Maybe the best thing to come out of this book was a quote from the author's husband's geometry teacher: "Anything worth doing is worth doing wrong."

Do I really believe that?  Do I teach like that is true?  Because it definitely is.  And, I need to make this my mantra.  If a problem is truly worth doing, then it is worth it for my students to do it wrong.  There is something to be gleaned in the process of analyzing errors.

To try next year:

Problem Solving Strategy Gallery Walk

1.  Pick an awesome, thought-provoking problem for which the answer is not immediately apparent.
2.  List various (applicable) problem-solving strategies on strips of paper.
3.  Let each student draw a strip of paper.  Give them 3/5/10 minutes to apply that strategy to the problem.
4.  On a sheet of paper, they must illustrate how the strategy can be used.  However, they CANNOT solve the problem.  They should draw the picture, make the table, write the equation.  They should not answer the question.  That will come later.
5.  Hang the papers around the classroom.
6.  Give each student 3/4/5 post-it notes.
7.  Students must walk around the room and leave constructive feedback on the strategies employed by their classmates.
8.  Once feedback has been given, group students by strategy.  All of the students who drew a picture sit together.  All of the students who made a table sit together.  All of the students who wrote an equation sit together.
9.  Each group takes the feedback provided by their classmates and works the problem together, coming to a singular solution.  (Students may work problems individually first and then come together for a group solution.)
10.  Each group presents their solution and explains how they used their problem solving strategy.

Why I think I will like this:
* Emphasis on multiple avenues available to solve a problem
* Students giving students feedback - there's not enough of this in my classroom
* It will force me to ask more deeper, more complex, more thought-provoking questions

Thoughts?  Feedback?

I realize that problems are going to take longer this way.  We might spend an entire 50-minute period on one question.  But, is that a bad thing?  I've spent the last two years rushing through class period after class period to make sure I "cover" everything.  No wonder they forget everything from the first semester by the time the end of year test comes around.  Students learn and internalize what we dwell on.  And, problem solving strategies is something I need to dwell on.  Few of my students will ever factor polynomials or graph exponentials as part of their daily lives.  But, they will all face problems that need to be solved, and they will need tools to help them sort through the many options available to them.  If they leave my classroom as critical thinkers and problem solvers who persevere until a solution is found, I have done my job.

Older Post ►
 

Copyright 2011 Math equal LOVE is proudly powered by blogger.com